Yankees vs Blue Jays Prediction, Odds, Moneyline, Spread & Over/Under for May 19

Odds updated as of 1:11 a.m.

The New York Yankees are among the MLB teams busy on Tuesday, versus the Toronto Blue Jays.

Here's everything you need to know before checking out today's MLB odds and spreads on FanDuel Sportsbook.

Yankees vs Blue Jays Game Info

• New York Yankees (29-19) vs. Toronto Blue Jays (21-26)
• Date: Tuesday, May 19, 2026
• Time: 7:05 p.m. ET
• Venue: Yankee Stadium -- The Bronx, New York
• Coverage: TBS, YES, and SN1

Yankees vs Blue Jays Odds & Moneyline

• All MLB odds, betting lines and prop bets are available on FanDuel Sportsbook.
• Moneyline: NYY: (-142) | TOR: (+120)
• Spread: NYY: -1.5 (+146) | TOR: +1.5 (-176)
• Total: 8.5 -- Over: (-115) | Under: (-105)

Yankees vs Blue Jays Probable Starting Pitchers

Probable Pitchers: Will Warren (Yankees) - 5-1, 3.42 ERA vs Dylan Cease (Blue Jays) - 3-1, 2.41 ERA

The probable pitchers are Will Warren (5-1) for the Yankees and Dylan Cease (3-1) for the Blue Jays. When Warren starts, his team is 6-3-0 against the spread this season. Warren's team is 7-2 this season when he starts and they are the moneyline favorite. When Cease starts, the Blue Jays have gone 5-4-0 against the spread. The Blue Jays were the underdog on the moneyline for one Cease start this season -- they won.

Yankees vs Blue Jays Prediction & Pick

All MLB win probability predictions and picks are according to numberFire.
Prediction: Yankees win (56.7%)

Yankees vs Blue Jays Moneyline

• The Yankees vs Blue Jays moneyline has New York as a -142 favorite, while Toronto is a +120 underdog on the road.

Yankees vs Blue Jays Spread

• The Blue Jays are +1.5 on the run line against the Yankees. The Blue Jays are -176 to cover, and the Yankees are +146.

Yankees vs Blue Jays Over/Under

• A combined run total of 8.5 has been set for Yankees-Blue Jays on May 19, with the over at -115 and the under at -105.

Bet on New York Yankees vs. Toronto Blue Jays on FanDuel today!

Yankees vs Blue Jays Betting Trends

• The Yankees have been victorious in 26, or 61.9%, of the 42 contests they have been chosen as favorites in this season.
• New York has a record of 18-9 in contests when sportsbooks favor them by -142 or more on the moneyline.
• Contests with the Yankees have gone over the total set by bookmakers in 20 of 46 chances this season.
• The Yankees are 24-22-0 against the spread in their 46 games with a line set by sportsbooks this season.
• The Blue Jays have gone 5-14 in games they were the underdog on the moneyline (winning 26.3% of those games).
• Toronto is 1-4 (winning only 20% of its games) when playing as a moneyline underdog of +120 or longer.
• In the 47 games bookmakers have set an over/under for the Blue Jays, they have combined with opponents to go over the total 24 times (24-23-0).
• The Blue Jays have put together a 21-26-0 record ATS this season (covering 44.7% of the time).

Yankees Player Leaders

• Aaron Judge leads New York with a slugging percentage of .590, fueled by 24 extra-base hits. He has a .266 batting average and an on-base percentage of .398.
• Among all qualifying hitters, he ranks 56th in batting average, his on-base percentage ranks ninth, and he is sixth in slugging.
• Cody Bellinger has hit six homers this season while driving in 32 runs. He's batting .271 this season and slugging .476 with an on-base percentage of .377.
• He ranks 48th in batting average, 25th in on-base percentage and 40th in slugging in the major leagues.
• Bellinger has picked up a hit in two games in a row. In his last five games he is hitting .200 with a double, a home run, three walks and three RBIs.
• Ben Rice leads New York with 45 hits and an OBP of .400 this season.
• Rice brings a two-game hitting streak into this game. During his last five outings he is batting .227 with a double, two home runs, a walk and two RBIs.
• Trent Grisham is batting .166 with a .297 OBP and 27 RBI for New York this season.

Blue Jays Player Leaders

• Vladimir Guerrero Jr. has accumulated an on-base percentage of .374, a team-high for the Blue Jays. He's batting .285 and slugging .378.
• Including all the qualifying players in MLB, he ranks 33rd in batting average, 27th in on-base percentage and 111th in slugging percentage.
• Ernie Clement paces his team with a .406 slugging percentage. He has a batting average of .283 with an on-base percentage of .309.
• He is currently 36th in batting average, 116th in on-base percentage and 81st in slugging percentage among all qualified hitters.
• Kazuma Okamoto is leading the Blue Jays with 39 hits.
• Daulton Varsho is batting .261 with nine doubles, a triple, five home runs and 15 walks.

Yankees vs Blue Jays Head to Head

• 5/18/2026: 7-6 NYY (Favorite: Yankees, Spread: -1.5, Total: 9, Favorite Moneyline: -178, Underdog Moneyline: +150)
• 10/7/2025: 9-6 NYY (Favorite: Yankees, Spread: -1.5, Total: 8, Favorite Moneyline: -172, Underdog Moneyline: +144)
• 10/5/2025: 13-7 TOR (Favorite: Yankees, Spread: -1.5, Total: 8, Favorite Moneyline: -154, Underdog Moneyline: +130)
• 10/4/2025: 10-1 TOR (Favorite: Blue Jays, Spread: -1.5, Total: 8.5, Favorite Moneyline: -118, Underdog Moneyline: -100)
• 9/7/2025: 4-3 NYY (Favorite: Yankees, Spread: -1.5, Total: 8, Favorite Moneyline: -180, Underdog Moneyline: +152)
• 9/6/2025: 3-1 NYY (Favorite: Yankees, Spread: -1.5, Total: 10, Favorite Moneyline: -138, Underdog Moneyline: +118)
• 9/5/2025: 7-1 TOR (Favorite: Yankees, Spread: -1.5, Total: 9, Favorite Moneyline: -126, Underdog Moneyline: +108)
• 7/23/2025: 8-4 TOR (Favorite: Yankees, Spread: -1.5, Total: 8, Favorite Moneyline: -142, Underdog Moneyline: +120)
• 7/22/2025: 5-4 NYY (Favorite: Blue Jays, Spread: -1.5, Total: 9, Favorite Moneyline: -112, Underdog Moneyline: -104)
• 7/21/2025: 4-1 TOR (Favorite: Yankees, Spread: -1.5, Total: 8.5, Favorite Moneyline: -120, Underdog Moneyline: +102)

Sign up for FanDuel Sportsbook and FanDuel Daily Fantasy today!